When discussing the greatest point guard in NBA history, two names stand out above the rest, Magic Johnson and Stephen Curry. Both players revolutionized the game in their own way, but who truly holds the crown as the GOAT point guard?
Some argue that Magic’s leadership, size, and passing ability make him the ultimate floor general. Others believe that Steph’s shooting, impact on modern basketball, and championship success give him the edge.
Let’s break down both sides of the debate and determine if Stephen Curry has already surpassed Magic Johnson, or if he still has more to prove.
Magic Johnson – The Ultimate Floor General
A 6’9” Point Guard Ahead of His Time
Magic Johnson wasn’t just a great point guard, he redefined the position. At 6’9”, he was an anomaly, blending size, vision, and skill like no player before him. His ability to push the tempo, make pinpoint passes, and control the game’s flow made him the engine behind the Lakers’ legendary “Showtime” dynasty.
Magic’s Accolades & Achievements:
5× NBA Champion (1980, 1982, 1985, 1987, 1988)
3× NBA MVP (1987, 1989, 1990)
3× NBA Finals MVP
10× NBA All-Star, 9× All-NBA Team
NBA’s All-Time Leader in Assists Per Game (11.2 APG)
Magic’s Defining Moment: The 1980 NBA Finals
Magic’s legend was cemented early in his career. In the 1980 NBA Finals, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar was ruled out with an injury for Game 6. At just 20 years old, Magic stepped in at center, dropped 42 points, 15 rebounds, and 7 assists, and led the Lakers to a championship.
That performance alone showed his versatility, leadership, and winning mentality.
The Magic Johnson Legacy
Magic wasn’t known for his shooting, he only made 325 career three-pointers, but his playmaking, leadership, and impact on winning made him arguably the best point guard in history. He led the Lakers to nine Finals appearances in 12 seasons, proving he was the heart of one of the greatest dynasties ever.
If your definition of a GOAT point guard is someone who orchestrates an offense, makes teammates better, and dominates the game with passing and leadership, Magic Johnson is the clear answer.
Stephen Curry: The Greatest Shooter Ever
The Point Guard Who Changed the Game
Magic may have redefined the point guard position, but Stephen Curry revolutionized basketball itself. The greatest shooter in NBA history, Curry stretched the limits of what was possible, forcing defenses to guard 35 feet away from the basket and inspiring an entire generation to prioritize the three-point shot.
Curry’s Accolades & Achievements (So Far):
4× NBA Champion (2015, 2017, 2018, 2022)
2× NBA MVP (2015, 2016) [Only Unanimous MVP in History]
1× NBA Finals MVP (2022)
10× NBA All-Star, 9× All-NBA Team
NBA’s All-Time Leader in Three-Pointers Made
Career 24+ PPG, 43% from Three
Steph’s Defining Moment: The 2022 NBA Finals
Despite already having three championships, some critics claimed Steph needed a Finals MVP to solidify his legacy. In 2022, he responded with one of the greatest Finals performances ever, averaging 31.2 PPG and dropping a 43-point masterpiece in Game 4 to lead the Warriors over the Celtics.
This win proved he could carry a team to a title without Kevin Durant, cementing his legacy as an all-time great.
How Curry Changed the Game
- Greatest Shooter Ever: No debate here. He has more made threes than anyone in history, and he’s still playing.
- Gravity Unlike Any Other: Defenses panic the second he crosses half-court, opening up easy shots for teammates.
- Elite Handles & Off-Ball Movement: Unlike Magic, who dominated with size, Steph moves off the ball constantly, making him impossible to guard.
- Revolutionized Basketball: Before Steph, teams didn’t take 40+ threes a game. Now? It’s the new normal—and he’s the reason why.
If you believe a GOAT point guard is defined by individual skill, game-changing impact, and championship success, then Curry is your answer.
Comparing Magic & Steph: Who Has the Edge?
| Category | Magic Johnson | Stephen Curry |
|---|---|---|
| Championships | 5 Rings | 4 Rings (Still Playing) |
| MVPs | 3× MVP | 2× MVP (Only Unanimous Ever) |
| Scoring | 19.5 PPG | 24.8 PPG |
| Assists | 11.2 APG | 6.4 APG |
| Shooting | 30% from three | 43% from three (All-Time Leader) |
| Playoff Dominance | 9 Finals in 12 seasons | 6 Finals in 9 years |
| Impact on the Game | Showtime Lakers, Changed PG Role | Revolutionized Three-Point Era |
The X-Factor: Steph Still Has Time to Add to His Legacy
One major factor in this debate? Curry isn’t done yet.
At 36 years old, Steph is still playing at an elite level and could add more rings to his collection. If he wins a fifth or sixth championship, his case against Magic gets even stronger.
Imagine this scenario:
- Curry wins another ring—he matches Magic’s five titles.
- Curry wins another MVP—he solidifies his individual dominance.
- Curry sets more all-time records—his GOAT status grows even more.
Wouldn’t that make him the undisputed best point guard of all time?
Final Verdict: Who is the GOAT Point Guard?
So, who’s the greatest point guard in NBA history?
- If you prioritize leadership, passing, and dominance in an era before the three-point revolution, Magic Johnson is your guy.
- If you value shooting, game-changing impact, and modern dominance, then Stephen Curry takes the crown.
The debate is far from over, especially with Steph still playing.
But now, we want to hear from YOU! Who do you think is the GOAT point guard? Drop a comment below and let’s keep the conversation going!
team to beat 
Leave a comment